Why Punishment and Rewards Don’t Work
Most parents want the same things. They want their kids to grow up respectful, kind, emotionally intelligent, and confident. And for decades, many parenting approaches promised that clear rewards and firm punishments were the way to get there. Charts, time-outs, gold stars, privileges taken away, toys earned back — these strategies often seem to work in the short term. But over time, many parents find themselves asking the same question: Why do I have to keep doing this over and over? Why doesn’t it stick?
The answer lies in what punishment and rewards actually teach. They focus on compliance, not connection. They shape behaviour through external control, not internal growth. And while they may change what a child does in the moment, they rarely help a child understand why that behaviour matters — or what to do differently next time.
Positive parenting offers a different path. It focuses on emotional safety, consistent boundaries, and long-term relationship building. Instead of teaching kids to behave out of fear or to perform for praise, it helps them develop emotional awareness, responsibility, and a real understanding of how their actions affect others. This approach takes more time, more patience, and more reflection — but it also lasts.
So, why don’t punishment and rewards work the way we hope?
Punishment often teaches avoidance, not accountability. A child who is sent to their room may learn not to hit their sibling in front of you, but they may not learn how to handle anger or conflict. The behaviour is hidden, not transformed. Over time, punishment can create fear, shame, and disconnection. The child may comply to avoid getting in trouble, but not because they understand the impact of their actions. And when that external pressure is gone, the behaviour often returns.
Rewards may feel more positive, but they carry similar risks. They can shift a child’s motivation from internal to external — from I want to do the right thing to What will I get if I do this? Over time, children may become more focused on outcomes than on effort or meaning. They might help clean up because there’s a sticker involved, but not because they feel invested in contributing to the family. And when the reward is removed, motivation often disappears along with it.
Both punishment and rewards also send a message that love and approval are conditional. When a child behaves in the way we want, we show warmth and praise. When they misbehave, we withdraw or scold. This creates emotional confusion, especially for younger children. They begin to wonder if their worth depends on their behaviour. And while we may not mean to send that message, it’s often how they experience it.
In contrast, positive parenting begins with the belief that all behaviour is communication. A meltdown, a refusal, a defiant tone — these are not just problems to fix. They are signals that something deeper is happening. Maybe the child feels overwhelmed, misunderstood, disconnected, or powerless. When we respond with curiosity rather than control, we can begin to understand what our child actually needs — and support them in ways that foster growth rather than fear.
This doesn’t mean letting go of limits. Positive parenting is not permissive. It’s not about letting kids run the show or avoiding discipline altogether. It’s about setting boundaries with empathy and clarity, and staying in relationship even when things get hard. It’s about saying, “I won’t let you hit your brother, and I’m here to help you figure out another way to show your frustration.” It’s about staying present during the storm, not sending the child away to deal with it alone.
In the long run, this approach helps children learn emotional regulation. They begin to understand their own feelings, their impact on others, and the tools they can use to repair and reconnect. They develop a stronger internal compass — not one shaped by fear of consequences or desire for rewards, but by empathy, confidence, and emotional intelligence.
Parents often ask, “But doesn’t my child need to learn consequences?” And the answer is yes — but not all consequences need to be imposed. Natural consequences, especially when processed with support, are far more effective. If a child forgets their homework and feels frustrated at school, they’re learning. If a teen speaks unkindly and notices that others are hurt, they’re learning. Our role as parents is to help them understand and reflect, not to pile on additional shame or control.
It’s also helpful to remember that kids are still learning how to behave. They are growing brains in growing bodies. They will make mistakes. They will forget what you said yesterday. They will be impulsive, emotional, and unfiltered. This is part of development — not defiance. Positive parenting meets them where they are, offers tools they can actually use, and helps them grow through relationship, not rigidity.
And while this approach requires more emotional energy up front, it also brings more peace and trust in the long term. You’ll spend less time enforcing rules and more time connecting. You’ll see fewer power struggles and more cooperation. And your child will begin to trust that they can come to you — not just when they’re doing well, but when they’re struggling too.
If punishment and rewards have stopped working in your home — or if they never really felt right to begin with — there is another way. Positive parenting gives you tools to respond with calm, to set boundaries with kindness, and to build a relationship that guides your child from the inside out.
Counsellors in Victoria, BC
We are counsellors in Victoria, BC. Choose one of our therapists who feels like the best fit for you and your family, and book a free consultation call so we can get you started. Let’s take the next step together toward clarity, calm, and connection right where it matters most.
